Scoring Safeguards

How Carmen protects your awards ceremony

Before a single award is read aloud, Carmen checks that every score is in, every award has a winner, and a person has certified the results.

Three checks before the awards script

Every score in, every award filled, then a person certifies.

  1. Every score is in before results lock

    For competitive rounds, a division or round locks only when every assigned scoring judge has entered every score their captions and scoring method require. Comments-only and timing judges don't hold up the lock. Results can't be finalized from partial scores.

  2. Every award has a winner

    The awards script can't be generated until every award has a winner, whether it comes from the scores or from a special awards judge. A tie for a caption award has to be broken first.

  3. A person certifies the awards

    Once the script is built, an admin reviews and certifies it, including finals qualifiers. Every division in the script must be locked first. Until the awards are certified, the script can't go to your announcer or be exported, and once they're certified the script can't be edited unless certification is withdrawn.

These checks have been in place since the 2026 season.

Ties are decided by rules set in advance

When groups finish equal under a method's primary score, Carmen applies that division's tie-break rules—defaults differ by method, and hosts can set their own order. Broken ties show which rule decided them on the published awards; if every step stays equal the award is shared. Category ties need an admin decision, and a hand break needs a written note. See how ties are broken on the methods page.

Why finalists are entered by hand

Qualification is not the same as a guaranteed finals slot.

Carmen doesn't copy prelim qualifiers into finals automatically. A group that qualifies can be disqualified or withdraw before finals and be replaced by another group, so the host sets the finals lineup.

When a finals round is linked to its preliminary round, judges scoring finals can see their own prelim scores for context. Linked finals rounds stay off the public schedule until the host chooses to make them visible—so the public lineup does not leak finals before you are ready.

How penalties work

Timing records each performance; applying a penalty is a deliberate step.

Group rounds can have a timing judge with a dedicated stopwatch screen. The timing judge records each performance's length and can draft time penalties, but a penalty affects results only when the timing judge or host applies it with Apply Penalties to Results. Nothing changes the standings by accident in the middle of a performance.

A penalty of the same size doesn't weigh the same under every method. Under total-points methods it comes off the total, under average-based methods it comes off the average, and under rank-based methods it's applied to the scores before ranks are calculated. Set penalty sizes with your scoring method in mind. See the scoring methods page for how each method works.

Corrections

If something needs to change after results lock.

A locked division has to be unlocked to change a score, then corrected and locked again, so the completeness check runs again. Unlocking hides published results until they are published again; publishing again notifies directors again. If the public already saw the earlier results, an admin adds a dated correction note on the published results and awards. If the awards are already certified, certification has to be withdrawn and redone before the script can change. Once results are published, penalties and award overrides also need an unlock before they can change.

Questions about your contest's awards?

Ask us about locking, certification, finals or timing penalties for your next contest.